Personally, I do remember the penis size of my first, but only because he was so big that it really hurt to have sex.
Many women will bleed all over the sheets and bed like they have been mortally stabbed.
He seemed straight enough to me while we were bathing in that mountain stream, but, before you know it, he's sucking my cock! And where did he get those fantastic boots? I'm 15, 16 in a few months.